Wendy's sittin' next to me
She's trying hard to drink it away 
And I feel the rumble of the subway 
Beneath the stage 
And her eyes are screaming
And her lips are pursed
And this ain't her first heartache 
But it feels like, it feels like the worst 
And she says
Can someone tell me how this can happen 
And I guess that God only knows
My heart used to be 
The sweet shop of love 
But now the sign on the door 
It says sorry we're closed 
And I hear myself tell her 
Some old words I know they won't help 
And then I feel guilty 
'Cause I closed some sweet shops myself 
And we all talk about timing 
And lifestyles and such 
But to a heart that's been shattered
Those words don't mean that much 
And all of our pining 
It just goes to show 
Don't you enter a shop
With the sign on the door
Saying sorry we're closed
And she's been through all the pain
That one can endure 
And her new man thinks she loves him 
But he can't be sure 
And his heart pines for Wendy 
She says that's how it goes
How am I supposed to know 
He can't read the sign saying 
Sorry we're closed 
Yeah we're closed 
And she says 
Can someone tell me how this can happen
And I guess that God only knows
My heart used to be
The sweet shop of love
But there's a sign on the door
There's a sign on the door
One more sign...