Lookin' back I'd have to say 
I dropped the ball again 
I let you slip through my fingertips 
Now I'm payin' in the end 
I let you go, I watched you leave 
I guess the jokes on me 
When I lay with her at night 
You're all I see 

She ain't bad but she ain't you 
I guess she'll have to do 
I can't keep my mind from goin' back in time 
And wishin' that we weren't through 
She may hold me, and she may love me 
But she can't melt me like you do 
I know it's wrong to say it 
She ain't bad but she ain't you 

She don't do nothin' wrong 
She's more than I deserve 
But if I can turn back the hands of time 
It's you instead of her 
I had you once, I let you go 
You won't be comin' back 
So I'll be right here with her 
Dreamin' about our past 

[Chorus]

I know it's wrong to say it 
She ain't bad but she ain't you