You're pretty dreamy for a boy from 
Long island 
You should come to see me on my 
Western horizon 
Seems as though it's cause we're never meant to meet 
But I just look at you and know you're pretty sweet 
I want to set a place for you at my table 
We can sit forever watching reruns on cable 
Take you driving in my brother's beat old car 
Sharing a cigarette and wish upon a star together 

So you say you like my shirt 
(i like your shirt) 
And you say you've got a lot just like them 
(I've got a lot just like them) 
And I hear you wrote a song about me 
By definition, a crush must hurt 
And they do 
And they do 
Just like the one I have on you. 

I want to set a place for you at my table 
We can sit forever watching reruns on cable 
Seems as though it's cause we're never meant to meet 
But I just look at you and know you're pretty sweet 

So you say you like my shirt 
And you say you've got a lot just like them 
And I hear you wrote a song about me 
By definition, a crush must hurt 
And they do 
And they do 
Just like the one I have on you. 

You're pretty dreamy for a boyfriend 
Long island 
You should come to see me on my 
Western horizon 
Take you driving in my brother's beat up car 
Sharing a cigarette and wish upon a star together