Even in my heart I see
You're not being true to me
Deep within' my soul I feel
Nothing's like it used to be
Sometimes I wish I could turn back time
Impossible as it may seem
But I wish I could so bad, baby
 
Quit playin' games with my heart
With my heart, my heart
I should've known from the start
With my heart, my heart, my heart
 
I live my life the way
To keep you coming back to me
Everything I do is for you
So what is it that you can't see
Sometimes I wish I could turn back time
Impossible as it may seem
But I wish I could so bad, baby
 
You better quit playin' games with my heart
With my heart, my heart
I should've known from the start
With my heart, my heart, my heart
 
Baby, baby, the love that we had was so strong
Don't leave me hangin' here forever
Oh baby, baby, this is not right
Let's stop this tonight
 
Na, na, na...
Quit playin' games with my heart